I used pigeon cream, but never tries other brand so I can't really make comparison. Pigeon worked ok for me. I didn't use often as I didn't like the idea of my baby swallowing the cream although it said completely safe. Best natural way to moisture n soothe cracked nipple is by squirting a bit of breastmilk and apply it on your nipple. Anyway cracked or sore nipple is temporary while your skin is adjusting to baby's tongue and the friction. After a while, you wouldn't need the cream anymore..